America loves its pumpkin spice lattes. But as any coffee addict knows, those fancy drinks don’t come cheap. The good news? With the right coffee flavor syrups, you can make cafe-worthy flavors at home for a fraction of the price. But with so many flavored syrup brands on the market, how do you pick one that actually tastes great in your morning mug?
We did the tough work for you. We sampled and ranked 12 best coffee syrup brands based on the flavors that came through when added to plain old drip coffee. From cheap gallons sold by the barrel to artisanal syrups crafted in small batches, we tried them all. In this guide, we’ll walk you through what to expect from the best flavored syrups for coffee you can buy today.
For each brand, we’ll discuss the hits and misses when it comes to taste, ingredients, variety of flavors offered, and how easy it is to get your hands on a bottle. Read on to discover which coffee syrup came out on top to create delicious lattes, creamy mochas, and other coffeehouse-worthy drinks without leaving your kitchen. Spoiler: The winner might surprise you!